Short answer: Yes, it can, and the data it gives you is too unreliable to be worth the risk. Turn open tracking off unless a step in your sequence depends on it, and judge your campaigns by replies instead.
Last checked: 16 November 2026. Tool settings and sender rules change, so check the provider’s own site before you change anything.
Open tracking feels like free information. You send a campaign, and within minutes you can see who opened it, when, and how many times. For a founder sending their first cold emails, that feedback is reassuring. The problem is that the information costs you something, and it is mostly wrong anyway.
What open tracking actually does
Open tracking works by hiding a tiny invisible image, a tracking pixel, inside your email. When the recipient’s email app loads images, it requests that pixel from your sending tool’s server, and the tool records an open. That is the whole mechanism, and it has two consequences that matter.
First, your email must be sent as HTML for the pixel to exist at all. Plain text emails cannot carry one. Second, an open is only recorded when images load, which means your open rate measures image loading as much as it measures reading. Both of these facts are at the root of the deliverability problem.
Why it can hurt deliverability
Spam filters look for signs that an email is bulk mail, and a tracking pixel is one of those signs. It tells the filter that the sender is watching recipients, which is exactly what bulk senders do and what one-to-one senders rarely do. A pixel on its own will not send a good email to spam, but it adds weight to the pile, and for a new domain with no sending history, that weight matters.
The HTML requirement adds a second problem. Plain text cold emails look like a person wrote them, and they tend to land in the inbox more easily. HTML emails with images, styling and a tracking pixel look like marketing mail. If your sending domain is new, or your list is untested, that difference in appearance is real. Our deliverability guide explains the full picture, including authentication, warmup and list hygiene, which matter more than any single setting.
What the tools themselves say
This is not just folk wisdom from forums. The tools that sell open tracking tell you to switch it off for cold outreach. Instantly Academy recommends sending cold email with open tracking off, and Snov.io gives the same advice. Hunter takes a more cautious view, noting that tracking has a place in some workflows, but even there the default for cold campaigns is off. When the people who built the feature tell you not to use it for this job, that is worth listening to.
The reason is simple: the feature was built for opted-in marketing email, where the sender and the recipient already have a relationship and the tracking pixel is expected. Cold email is a different job, and the settings that work for newsletters are not the settings that work for outreach to strangers.
The data is unreliable anyway
Even if tracking cost you nothing, the numbers would not be worth much. Apple Mail Privacy Protection, switched on for most Apple Mail users since 2021, loads images remotely and reports opens that never happened. Gmail caches images too, which inflates open counts in a different way. The result is that reported open rates are almost always higher than real open rates, and the gap is not consistent, so you cannot even correct for it.
Discussions on r/coldemail in February to April 2026 make the same point from the other side. Threads titled along the lines of stop tracking open rates report that turning tracking off made no visible difference to replies, and one practitioner reported a small reply rate lift of about 0.4 points after switching it off, with no sample size given, so treat that as an anecdote, not evidence. The consistent theme is that nobody who turns it off misses the data.
That is the key point. Open rate is a vanity metric for cold email. A high open rate with no replies means your subject line worked and your email did not, and you would know that from the reply rate alone. A low open rate tells you very little, because it may mean your emails went to spam, or it may mean images were blocked, and the tracking cannot tell the two apart.
What to measure instead
Judge a campaign by its reply rate, and judge deliverability by placement, not by opens. Send a test to your own Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo inboxes before a campaign goes out, and check where it lands. Watch your bounce rate, which should stay under 2 percent, and your spam complaint rate, which should stay under 0.1 percent. Those four numbers tell you the truth about a campaign. Our cold email metrics guide explains each one, with the benchmarks worth aiming for in 2026.
When to leave open tracking on
There are two genuine exceptions. The first is when a step in your sequence depends on opens, for example a branch that sends a different follow-up to people who opened but did not reply. If you use that kind of branching, keep tracking on for that campaign, and accept the small deliverability cost as the price of the workflow. The second is when a client or a manager insists on seeing open rates in a report. In that case, track opens on a small test segment and send the main campaign without tracking.
Outside those two cases, turn it off. Your emails will look more like personal mail, your deliverability will improve slightly, and you will stop optimising for a number that was never telling you the truth.
How to turn it off
In most sending tools the setting is one toggle, usually labelled open tracking, in the campaign settings or the workspace settings. In Instantly, turn off open tracking in the campaign settings before you launch. In Snov.io, the same toggle sits in the campaign setup. Change it once, and check it again before every new campaign, because some tools reset it when you duplicate a campaign.
Then give it a week. Send your next campaign with tracking off, compare the reply rate with your last tracked campaign, and see for yourself. That is the only test that matters, and it is the test that convinces most people to leave it off for good.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, it can. The tracking pixel is a signal spam filters associate with bulk mail, and tracking forces your email to be HTML rather than plain text, which also looks more like marketing mail. Turn it off unless a step in your sequence depends on it.
Yes, for cold campaigns. Instantly Academy itself recommends sending cold email with open tracking off. Keep it on only if a sequence step branches on opens, and accept the small deliverability cost in that case.
Track reply rate as your main campaign metric, and track deliverability with inbox placement tests to your own Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo accounts, plus bounce rate under 2 percent and spam complaint rate under 0.1 percent.
No. With tracking off, your tool records no open data at all. That is the trade-off, and it is worth making, because the open data was inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection and Gmail image caching and could not be trusted anyway.